W Keeler
Another victory for FREE SPEECH. This time it was struck by the Court of Queen’s Bench in Alberta, Dec.3, that overturned the Alberta Human Rights Commission (AHRC) ruling against Stephen Boission for writing and sending
a scurrilous letter against homosexuality which had been published June 17, 2002 in the Red Deer Advocate.
Five years later, November 29, 2007, the
AHRC announced their ruling: “paragraph 357 excerpt “In this case, the publication's exposure of homosexuals to hatred and contempt trumps the freedom of speech afforded in the Charter. It cannot be the case that any speech wrapped in the `guise' of politics or religion is beyond reproach by any legislation but the Criminal Code”.
Several months later came the
“remedy”.14. The Panel finds, and the Panel orders as follows:
a.
That Mr. Boissoin and The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc. shall cease publishing in newspapers, by email, on the radio, in public speeches, or on the internet, in future, disparaging remarks about gays and homosexuals. Further, all disparaging remarks versus homosexuals are directed to be removed from current web sites and publications of Mr. Boissoin and The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc.
b.
That The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc. and Mr. Boissoin shall, in future, be restrained from committing the same or similar contraventions of the Act.
c.
That Mr. Boissoin and The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc. provide Dr. Lund with a written apology for the article in the Red Deer Advocate which was the subject of this complaint.
d.
That Mr. Boissoin and The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc. shall request the Red Deer Advocate publish a copy this Order in the Red Deer Advocate and that they request their written apology for the contravention of the Act be published in the Red Deer Advocate.
e.
That Mr. Boissoin and The Concerned Christian Coalition Inc. shall pay to Dr. Lund an award for damages, jointly and severally, in the amount of $5,000.00
It is obvious that the remedies are ludicrous and unenforceable.
The
Canadian Constitution Foundation declared that “In spite of today’s court ruling, Albertans need to continue to exercise extreme caution when speaking about public policy issues, lest they offend someone who then files a human rights complaint. No citizen is safe from being subjected to a taxpayer-funded prosecution for having spoken or written something that a fellow citizen finds offensive.”